Tuesday, November 22, 2011

I quit the sugar quit



A confession: I'm off the wagon.

Yep, after all my bleating on about quitting sugar, I'm swallowing my sweet sugary words. In my defense, I did always say it was a trial and that I wanted to incorporate moderation back into my life - so in part I'm still on track. Not a complete hypocrite.

And I've learnt a lot in the last couple of months:

I have a big appetite. Many people say that quitting sugar decreases their appetite and makes them think about food less. Not me. I think I just have a huge appetite regardless!

I haven't experienced any physical changes. I had wondered if eating less sweet stuff would help with a few 'issues', but it hasn't. Worth a shot, though.

I understand my aversion to savouries. Remember when your parents would tell you to eat a meal so that you could have dessert? I've realised I haven't grown up - that's still my way of thinking. I tolerate savouries because I know I should, all the while wanting to get to the good bit. The best thing this last couple of months has taught me is to enjoy my meals more.

Extremes don't work for me. Not with food, anyway. It's got to the point where I can't think of what to eat, so I won't have anything - and not eating enough makes me feel terrible.

I've started feeling deprived. And when you feel deprived, you do weird things. I bought a chocolate bar at a supermarket on the way home one day. Then stopped again and bought another one. A packet of jelly beans another day. This binging is worse for me in a lot of different ways than just eating dessert now and then.

I've never felt guilty about food until recently. I've always had a healthy attitude towards food: if I feel hungry, I'll eat; if I feel like eating something, I will. No guilt, no calory counting, no questions. That has led to me eating more sweets than I probably should make a habit of, but on the whole I eat really well. I'm going back to that approach.

There are other reasons. A lot is going on right now and I feel I'm putting too much pressure on myself. On top of that is being on a medication that messes with my blood sugar levels - and so, if I feel off and need a quick sugar hit to get me through (before having something more sustaining) then I will.

And so I conclude that it was worth a try - and it has taught me a lot about how I eat, my attitude towards food, and it's made me more conscious of what I eat. Which is always a good thing.

Now I just need to remember that moderation is the key. It's what works for me.

Oh, and feel free to say you told me so.

 

36 comments:

  1. I've been toying with quitting sugar, but I just don't think I can. I love food. I love creme brulee and chocholate and jelly beans too ;) Moderation is definitely key. I'm starting to focus on filling up with healthy lower GI stuff. I can forget to eat sometimes and that's when I start reaching for the biscuits.
    Good on you for realising what works best for you. I wouldn't say I told you so at all ;)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have managed to drastically reduce sugar in my life, though I do slip when there are cookies, cupcakes or pies around. I agree, moderation is important. I also was told once to listen to my body, it will tell you what it likes and doesn't. So I try to do that, it has helped me quit eating fast food, cut back on sodas and drastically reduce the red meat I eat.

    I think you did great!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Im currently involved in a one-month life coaching challenge which involves, for me, giving up chocolate. The first week sucked but now its relatively easy. Am I going to give up chocolate altogether? No freakin way - it is one of my great loves :) But, like you, there has been some learning involved - much of which centres around moderation, improving health and keeping happy!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I didn't comment at the time when you wrote your original post, mainly because I understood where you were coming from and I think you are right. We have to try things to see if they are the right thing for us. If they aren't then that's fine. Good on you for giving it a go and realising it isn't the right thing for you. I would have died trying I suspect so appreciate you being my guinea pig ;)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Moderation in all things is indeed the way to go! However - if you have a tendency towards diabetes, then sugar is not a good thing to have at all. Husband is one and for years has INSISTED on three heaped teaspoons in his tea and coffee - result = diabetic numbers went haywire and he was put on insulin. We've now got it down to two flat ones, numbers are under better control - and he's going to lose another half a teaspoon soon (he doesn't know it yet!) and hopefully, the insulin doses can be lowered a bit too.

    Just be wary of too much sugar - and don't kid yourself that you need it for energy!

    All the best. Isobel

    ReplyDelete
  6. I won't say it, because I'm too kind and because I know that being sugar-free does work for some people. It's not something that I want to try, for many of the same reasons you listed. You need to do what feels right. The more I try to give up something, the more I want it. The more I tell myself I need to stop eating chocolate, the more likely I am to stock up and binge.

    I hope things settle down for you soon, maybe you can have some quiet family time over Christmas... Hugs...

    ReplyDelete
  7. Life is too short to quit sugar. It is all about moderation. You can not live without cake - you just can't!! x

    ReplyDelete
  8. I love your attitude Megan. Life is all about trying things out and then incorporating what works for you for the long term. Well done you.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I looked into the quitting sugar thing, and I was all ready to give it a go until I saw the no fruit (not sure if you did it that way or not though)
    And though it may be a cop out, with work and kids I don't have time to muck around making special meals.
    Anyway, as with most things I think it's about balance and moderation. I know eating a whole bag of snake lollies will give me a headache...I also know that my blood sugar can plummet and sometimes I need a quick hit to be able to drive home safely!
    I love that you were willing to give it a go, and willing to admit you stopped. Like I said before, life's a learning curve. :)

    ReplyDelete
  10. Moderation is definitely the key! I've tried to quit sugar several times before but have never lasted more than 4 days before I go INSANE and realise that I'm thinking about food all the time. And I mean ALL the time. Putting those kinds of restrictions on myself makes me do strange things like eat bags of chips at 8am and justifying it with "it's OK, they're sugar free!". Not cool. It's all about balance - eating well but still being able to treat yourself occasionally. xxx

    ReplyDelete
  11. During one of my Sealy Australia sleep challenges I was told to go cold turkey off caffeine and chocolate and it damn near killed me ! I was so cranky and it certainly didn't help with sleep so I caved after 3 days. The lesson honestly is everything in moderation - we all deserve a treat :)

    ReplyDelete
  12. Thanks Laney! It's all in the planning, I reckon - having good food on hand can stop the desperate reach for the chocolate and biscuits. Sometimes...

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thanks Muah - I think listening to our bodies is the best thing we can do.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thanks Sarah - glad I could save a life ;)

    ReplyDelete
  15. It's funny how easy it gets once you stop for a few days isn't it - the cravings disappear. Here's to health and happiness!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Thanks Isobel - so true, it's too easy to use energy as an excuse. Good luck with reducing your husband's sugar a bit more!

    ReplyDelete
  17. My mother-in-law said the same thing last night - life's too short. Just enjoy it. So true.

    ReplyDelete
  18. It seems to have worked wonders for so many. Ah well.

    Thanks Dorothy, I'm looking forward to things calming down a bit around here (which is wishful thinking, really!).

    ReplyDelete
  19. I did give up fruit, N - that was the easiest bit for me! Although, now that I've made it a forbidden thing I'm enjoying it more now that I'm back on it - how contrary is that!

    It's all about listening to our bodies, really, isn't it.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Wow, that's a big challenge! Glad you survived to tell the tale!

    ReplyDelete
  21. Me too, Jane - and to think about food more than I already do is something I thought was impossible! And I was doing the same thing - eating crap for breakfast because I couldn't have my porridge (can't eat it without brown sugar!). Which is strange logic, because I'm certain that porridge - despite having a sprinkling of sugar on top - is pretty damn healthy.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Oh thank God - I'm not the only one! I have been snootily telling people I'm 'not doing sugar', but have been off the wholesome, calorie-free wagon for weeks now! I've been doing crazy things too - buying a chocolate bar on the way home from work. Which is something I never did before 'going sugar-free' became my mantra. It is blood hard, isn't it? I think the moderation thing really does work - moderation in, deprivation out! Hurrah! :)

    ReplyDelete
  23. You did well to last several months, I only managed to last two weeks, but I came to pretty much the same conclusions as you. It's just not for me. I get the whole reasoning behind going sugar free and I can see it'd have long term benefits, but it's just not something I'd ever be able to keep up long term. I'm ok with that though. You tried it and you realised it wasn't for you. No harm or shame in that at all :)

    ReplyDelete
  24. I thought about quitting sugar, but I already don't eat cakes or biscuits or even dessert on a regular basis. I do eat chocolate a lot and could easily enough cut down. Apart from that the only sugar I have is the three teaspoons in my one cup of coffee a day. I know there are hidden sugars in a lot of processed foods, but I don't eat a lot of those, so I decided that quitting sugar isn't for me. I'll just cut back on the icecream and the chocolate.

    ReplyDelete
  25. You gave it your best shot, Megan and that's all you can ask of yourself. If it's not for you, then it seems futile to continue on that path. I doubt anyone would judge you for that.

    I've found quitting sugar to be easier than I thought it would be. I feel good and my daily headache has eased a lot. If it made no difference to my health, I'd be off the wagon in no time.

    Do what works for you :)

    ReplyDelete
  26. Our family has been low fructose for over a year now after reading David Gillespie's book. We do eat whole fruit as he suggests. We all feel amazing and there is no way I could eat it now. I am baking sweet treats for Christmas pressies and the smell of sugar and chocolate is overpowering.
    Can I suggest that it is hard to stop something that is addictive. Also hard to moderate. I was a chocolate bar a day girl and lived for desserts. Just not interested now.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I so wish I hadn't blogged about it in the first place, or told anyone - I should have tried quietly and then wouldn't have had to admit giving it up!

    ReplyDelete
  28. Just cutting back sounds like a good plan, Elsie. You sound like my husband, who doesn't care for many sweet things... but give him a pack of donuts or a cheesecake and he'll devour them! I guess we all have our weaknesses!

    ReplyDelete
  29. I'll definitely have to keep it in check and if I catch myself doing anything other than moderation, I'll have to do something about it. Well done, Vanessa, for finding something that works for you and your family :)

    ReplyDelete
  30. That's great, Jayne - and I absolutely can relate to the headaches and things. Years ago I was into softdrinks and way, way too much other sugar, and when I gave those the flick I felt so much clearer. It's so worth it to feel that way.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Honesty appreciated. I've still got the book there to read, but jumping on in the lead up to Christmas is probably not going to happen.
    I'm sure you've still walked away with something, some means of healthier eating.
    Moderation is definitely key.

    ReplyDelete
  32. [...] week has seen Fumbles & Bumbles pike out, and Writing out Loud quit too. Not very inspirational ladies! But I completely understand, it wasn’t right for you. Just [...]

    ReplyDelete
  33. Megan,

    Kudos to you for testing your theories to see what effect there would be on your body if you quit eating sugar. Everybody is different. Some people are more tolerant and can handle eating sugar without their body going bonkers.

    Although, there are other ways that sugar (and resulting insulin spikes) affects us all, like interfering with dopamine and seretonin levels, inhibiting brain functioning, inducing inflammation which is linked to heart attacks, etc. Also, eating sugar causes fat to build up around your internal organs. So even if a person doesn't appear to be overweight, there are definite dangers of overconsuming sugar (or eating sugar, at all), as you probably know.

    I quit eating sugar exactly a month ago, today. So far, I've had no sugar cravings. And since I'm eating a low carb, moderate protein, high fat diet (think Atkins), my hunger has been well-managed. Plus, there's always something I can eat that's low or no carbs. So there's never a need for me to go hungry.

    That said, I gather you've discovered that there's still a lot of work involved in adopting a diet without sugar. While I seem to be getting off scot-free with the sugar cravings, eating without sugar (and no starches or flour products either) and focusing on whole foods means a whole lot more thinking ahead, and planning needs to be a priority. It takes a LOT of time to prepare meals when you're always eating fresh veggies and not using boxed or microwaveable products.

    That said, I have no plans to go back to eating sugar. My wife and I have the attitude that this IS our lifestyle...there are no other options, therefore, we'll do what we gotta do...even when we don't feel like it, because this is how we eat now. I don't know if every one can do that, but with enough conviction, the option of eating sugar again never rises to the surface.

    Today, in America, it's Thanksgiving day....which is a holiday that centers around big feasts and bigger desserts. But at Thanksgiving dinner, my wife and I ate only the foods that did not contain sugar. Next up, Christmas, which usually includes Christmas cakes, cookies, and a plethera of sugary goodness. Just not for us....and I don't have a problem with that.

    Although, I should also say that just because I quit sugar and have no plans to going back to high-carb eating, I will have what I want when I want it....even a sweet treat. However, I know that it will be a very rare thing for me to choose to eat a sweet treat. But I will have it if I want it. The key for me is to only do that a few times per year, at most.

    This, I can live with.

    Thanks, Megan, for your honesty. I know you said that on the whole, you eat really well. So I wish you continued success with your diet and commend your intellegent approach to a healthy lifestyle.

    All the best,
    Scott

    ReplyDelete
  34. I tried to as well...i downloaded the e-book...I ate lots of vegies and lasted 22 days and then I had to hold maltesers in my hand for my 6 year old at a dancing concert (ie slow death) and it was as if each little crunchy ball was yelling 'eat me'...I failed.

    ReplyDelete