Friday, July 13, 2012

Why are people leaving the workforce? Let's talk about that.

News today: Australians are dropping out of the workforce at a never before seen rate.

All the stats and figures are quoted in the article - but really, you just need to look at some real life examples to know why. And, by coincidence, two people who have dropped out of the traditional workforce happen to live in this house.

Take my husband, Steve. He worked for twelve years for an enormous, global organisation, starting there when he left school and working his way up to management level. For most of that time, the work was challenging, the hours were long and he loved it - and then came a downturn in business, thousands retrenched, and his role became filling in for those who had gone. He was bored, but willing to stick it out. Until an opportunity came along, to work as a contractor doing something completely different.

The only certainty about his income was that it would fluctuate hugely from month to month, and he had to take a huge drop in pay to begin with. It was a risk.

There were two big upsides. Firstly, I was still in my corporate job and earning good money, so I could support us while we figured out if this change would work for us. Secondly, we were planning to start a family soon, and we could see that the hours of this new work would be much better suited.

Years later, and he's still doing that work and enjoying it. The income still fluctuates - as is the case for contracting work - but we've learned to manage it. The hours fluctuate too - one week we won't see him much, the next he'll be home lots, one week he might be working nights, the next days.

Mostly, his hours consist of starting early - before Abbey and I are even awake - and finishing early, which means he can spend afternoons with us. If he was still in his office job, he'd be lucky to see Abbey for an hour each evening.

So, while he's still in the workforce, leaving the traditional office environment meant a better family life for us.

Then there's me. Nine years with one organisation, starting at the bottom and working my way up to management level - and happy to stay there into the future. I worked full-time, studied at nights to be qualified for the field I worked in, and I enjoyed my work. Then I fell pregnant, went on maternity leave, returned to work when my baby was eight months old, ready to continue working life as usual - only to be told that full-time was the only option. No flexibility. I said, No way. Not yet.

I left with no idea where I was headed, but a strong determination that I had to find something that was a better fit with my family. Spending just an hour or two with my daughter each day wasn't right. After a long search, I realised that answer didn't lie in the corporate world - even their ideas of flexible work just weren't in the best interests of me seeing my daughter much at all.

Now, I'm a freelance writer - I write when it fits, which can mean on the days Steve is home early, or at nights and weekends. And as I build that up, the potential to earn a good income from it is looking positive.

I love writing; I also loved my corporate work. But I don't intend to ever go back to full-time or even rigid part-time hours in an office.

Traditional work couldn't - sorry, wouldn't - give me the chance to work and have what I believe to be a strong family life (or life in general).

Two very loyal, hard-working employees who were happy to stay with organisations long-term. Two people who were given no choice but to explore new opportunities. Two businesses who are losing out on not just us, but many other good workers due to their lack of foresight and flexibility.

Still wondering why people are leaving the workforce?

11 comments:

  1. One of the reasons that people are leaving the workforce in the UK is the lack of affordable childcare. Many working parents, mostly mothers, can't cover the costs so it's not worth them working. In my area, it has got to the point that many nurseries are advertising for the first time ever. Children get state funded nursery education grants after they turn 3 (roughly) so the nurseries are full of pre-schoolers as opposed to babies and toddlers.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think here in the US we are feeling the same. There is major disenfranchise and the younger generations don't feel like it is necessary to give a company your life when you are a number to them.

    I agree...when I start making enough writing I can't wait to do this full time.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Same here Megan. Hubby has spent a long time working free lance. Like you the money fluctuates, and we have learnt to manage it.
    He just can not get the flexibility he has working for corporates.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The thing is, not everyone is leaving the work force, many of us are finding the employers that are able to think beyond the work station box. Those employers are not having any trouble at all. But they are also not complaining and getting in the news about how things are going for them.

    Written from my work laptop, at home on my kitchen bench because it is school holidays and my work know that neither my boss or I will be physically in the office - but hey, call me at any time.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Megan, so much of what you've written has resonated with me. I spent seven years with one company and had to leave after being forced into a corner.

    I hate that often one partner is pushed to make sacrifices to support the other but in many ways I'm also grateful because my situation meant that I enrolled in university and looked at other ways of earning an income.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Many more people are leaving the workforce through no choice of their own. Companies are downsizing and letting people go. I see it on the news almost daily. Tonight it was Myer. And a couple of other compnaies, but I wasn't paying attention. Dozens of people will be laid off. Where will they all find jobs? when so many other places are also downsizing.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I could really go on and on about this, but I'll just say well said! Employers (as a general rule, and I know there are a lot of exceptions to the rule) don't seem to care about the employee, only the bottom line. There is such little flexibility it makes it really difficult. What happened to the days of people (and families) coming first.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Spot on as usual.

    I am amazed at the lack of foresight by so many employers. I hope they speed up to the real world soon, but I am not holding my breath - maybe by the time my girls are heading back to their careers?!

    I am now, after 8 years of working from home, working for a smaller company, with totally flexible hours (around the kids)for a high salary. It took me a lot of searching and negotiating to get to this point.

    My new company are wise - they now have me in golden handcuffs. I wont be going anywhere - they had me at "school hours"!

    All of the others? “Big mistake. Big. Huge.... I have to go shopping now.”!

    xx

    ReplyDelete
  9. As Claire says, some of us are lucky enough to have flexible employers. My last three employers have been that way inclined, after I left the job before that because they wouldn't afford me half a day a week to study (even though I was working 80 odd hours).

    I'm so grateful that there are organisations around that offer a proper, actual work life balance (not just 'you get to leave at 5pm on the dot!'). It makes for a much more fulfilling life on the whole.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Similar experience here when I returned from mat leave - full-time or no time. I felt the same as you. Sounds like you have a great balance going on x

    ReplyDelete