Monday, January 17, 2011

Why do we label our children?



We talked to her as we drove, practicing what she should say when we arrived. She replied enthusiastically: 'Yeah! Yay!'  while Steve and I muttered to each other, 'Sure, but she'll probably act all shy when we get there and not say a word.' Then I heard some talking from the backseat, quiet this time. I turned to see her, head down and saying 'Bit shy. Abbey's a bit shy.' We were a little shocked, and encouraged her some more and told her there was no need to be shy. 

When we arrived, she ran to her grandfather with her arms open and yelled, 'Happy birthday Opi!'

Sometimes you have these eye-opening moments as a parent, where everything suddenly makes sense. When you realise that every word you utter is heard. Despite the fact that she might be playing elsewhere, or chatting to herself or being noisy, she actually hears everything. And she understands.

Abbey is not a shy child, not by any stretch of the imagination. She never has been. She will run up to strangers without any qualms, introducing herself and chatting away like she's known them forever. She will run into a room and make herself at home straight away. She will take a child's hand and ask them to play, as though they're best friends. From the first day I took her to childcare, she turned and waved at me, saying ‘Bye Mummy!’

She is not a child prone to cuddling into me, or easing into things, or holding my hand uncertainly – in fact, there’s almost nothing worse in her mind. This is a girl who will run straight into any situation, with such confidence and enthusiasm that I am constantly amazed.

But recently, she started showing signs of developing some shyness. Someone would talk to her and she'd cuddle into me, hiding her face. I would explain to the person: 'She's been a bit shy lately'. And so, she wouldn't have to respond, to say hello nicely or answer a question. 'That's okay,' they'd say, 'she's shy'. And I'd nod and give my little girl a cuddle.


But then we realised the effect this was having on her. We came to understand that the labels we placed on her were doing more harm than good. It had become an excuse.

I was a shy child, and can at times be a shy adult, and I know plenty of children who are naturally shy. So I understood this feeling of shyness, or at least I thought I did. But then I realised, this is not about me, and this is not about other kids. This is about Abbey. This is about giving her the freedom to be her own person.

What she needed was encouragement, to be made to feel comfortable with being herself.

Lesson learnt.

No more labels.


19 comments:

  1. Spot on Megan!

    I still have to remind myself of this at times... you think I'd have learnt by now!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh my goodness my head is reeling with all the times I may have indirectly & unintentionally labelled my children! Thank you for sharing this experience. They sure do take in everything we say, even if we think they are not paying attention...

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yes, yes, yes! Only yesterday I was struggling with my husband who was telling me our youngest daughter was maybe autistic or "there's something different." he was telling me. I tried to explain to him that it's okay for her to be different to our eldest and that children believe what we tell them about themselves. I don't feel I got through and I am quite stressed about what may come of him placing irrelevant labels on her. I might just point him over here for a read.

    ReplyDelete
  4. and then there are the necessary labels. The ones you have to give your children to access help. Yes, all kids are different BUT it is terribly important not to dismiss concerns because early intervention can mean the difference between a functioning person and a non-functioning in the real world one.

    Yes, my child has a label, Asperger Syndrome. And I thank God everyday when I see the wonderful teenager he is becoming compared to the dire prognosis and incredibly challenged child he once was.

    He will move mountains BECAUSE he has a label. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great post, Megan. We all need this reminder. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  6. This is a great reminder that our kids hear everything. I need to be mindful of this, as I often get exasperated with my oldest for some of the things that he does that are lacking in common sense.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Perfect post Megan, I loved what you wrote. Even the labels inside our head have to be changed sometimes. Recently we took our 3 boys kayaking in the rain - it was cold and wet and 2 of them had kayaks that were challenging to say the least. Inside my head, I thought, child 1 will persevere and love this challenge and child 2 will be complaining and giving up within 5 minutes. I was totally wrong - it was almost the reverse. For me, it was another reminder not to stick to my own expectations of our kids - we think we know them so well yet ... maybe they have so much more to show us.

    ReplyDelete
  8. What lovely words Megan! It's so important to give kids the freedom to be themselves. It's funny that you talk about yourself being sometimes shy as an adult. I often say that about myself too and am wondering if that becomes a self-perptuating thing!

    ReplyDelete
  9. what a great lightbulb moment Megan. Yay for you and for Abbey. Now that my Batsman has an autism diagnosis I am especially conscious of labels and how we and others talk about him. Don't even get me started on the person (who shall remain nameless) who while watching my Batsman jump around on the couch said...."Oh he's just being stupid".....aaaaarrrggghhhhh.
    Love your blog x

    ReplyDelete
  10. We had exactly the same moment with Will at around that age.

    He sounds exactly like Abbey and then had this brief phase of taking slightly longer to warm up and we mentioned shyness and he really played up to it. He got to the point where he would say "I'm shy" and cover his eyes!

    It's amazing what they pick up on when you don't even think they are listening, and it really made it obvious to me how much they can try to play up to labels.

    It's why I am so anti people (like my MIL) saying, "oh, of course he is xyz" (loud, silly, naughty, messy) "because he is a boy"!! Drives me crazy.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I rarely comment, but this post resonated with me quite a lot. I hate the labels we place on kids - they're restrictive, especially gender labels. If I have to hear one more person say my 8 month old is "such a boy!" I'm going to scream! Gah!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Great post, Megan, and perfect timing for me right now. I have been guilty of labeling my kids on different occasions - and I've seen it play out. Thanks so much for the reminder!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Fantastic post Megan. So often we say things aloud without realising the effect they're having. Lesson learned here as well.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Wow, how though provoking! I admit I often fall into that trap as it is an easy solution. We adults do often forget that our kids process things we say differently that would an adult.

    ReplyDelete
  15. All the work I do is to raise awareness of parents and educators of the dangers of labels. thank you for such a wonderful post.

    ReplyDelete
  16. While I fully hear what you are saying I don't agree with it being a label at all. I think what your daughter is going through isn't being shy as much as not being sure of herself. So using the excuse that she is shy is only you using the wrong words and her hearing them.
    My daughter is shy. Always has been from the day she was born. We live in China and here people flock to her as if she prize attraction at the zoo. It freaks her out, to be kind about it. She spent 9 months with her arm over her face so people would not touch her face or poke their camera in it. As a parent it is my job to protect her from these things and to let people know that she isn't being rude she IS shy and they should respect that and give her the space she needs to grow and thrive. I encourage her to know she is safe from harm and let her set the pace on greeting the world. In doing so she is growing to be a happy 3 year old instead of one who hides in my skirts every time we are out. She knows I will keep people back and if they push through her comfort zone I'm there to help the fears from building. She no longer cries when we need to go out in public and unlike so many here I don't have an Ayi so she can't stay home when I do need to be out. As people grow older they find ways to work with their shyness. If you are not in their shoes you have no clue the courage they need in order to do things you think of as normal. You would have no clue the role playing they do. I think using labels is the cop out our generation is using for people. Everyone has something and we seem to thing the world would be better off if everyone wore a sign so we would know what slot to put them in.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Great post Meagan! And let me assure you, they are still hearing everything as teenagers, even though they might look like they are absorbed in an x-box!

    ReplyDelete
  18. I am also guilty of doing the exact same thing and one day I realised the effect it was having on Maxi. "I'm shy," he started announcing as he sauntered in and flopped himself down in the middle. NO you're not, I thought. Not anymore... but you're always going to believe you are. Why? Because Mummy told you and you believe every single thing I say.

    Silly Mummy!

    x

    ReplyDelete
  19. LOVE THIS!!! Absolutely agreed. Good job Mummy!! ;)

    ReplyDelete