Wednesday, February 1, 2012

This is what we should be telling all the kids in our lives

My little girl is due for her final check with the Maternal & Child Health Nurse next month, when she'll be three-and-a-half. I won't be taking her.

At all her baby checks we talked about how beautifully chubby she was. How healthy and clever and gorgeous and wonderful... all the usual gushy mother stuff. Then when she turned two, the conversation turned suddenly - to body mass indexes and obesity. A two-year-old. TWO!

Sure, she was still chubby. Yes, she was still above average in her weight (and also height, but that was never mentioned). Not once was I asked about her diet or activities or lifestyle. It was straight to the talk of BMI.

At the time, many people told me I was silly to have a problem with that. They're just trying to do their best to ensure obesity levels reduce, they'd say. Mums need to know this stuff.

I disagreed, and I still do.

By talking this way, the message is that we should be raising skinny kids. Not healthy, happy, intelligent, well-rounded (in life skills, I mean!) kids. Skinny.

They're saying it isn't important that my daughter has a balanced diet, that she's the healthiest child ever, that she's so active she'll walk anywhere with us, or that she's the happiest kid in the history of kids. They're saying they've forgotten what mums for hundreds of years have known: that a little chubbiness in a baby, toddler or child will set them up well for a good growth spurt. They're saying that being skinny would have been better than any of that.

I checked the graph in the health book the other day. I put my little girl's current weight and height into it, and when I saw that she's still in the 'above average' weight bracket, I made the decision not to take her for the check. (Although you should know that if I had any health concerns I'd take her to our family doctor; any developmental concerns and I'd be having those seen to as well.) I just don't want to have the conversation.

I don't think that a three-year-old needs to hear about her weight either. What she needs to hear are the things I tell her every day: that she's clever and kind and funny and beautiful. That we love her. That's it. It's our job as parents to monitor her health and happiness. It's her role as a kid to just have fun.

It scares me so much, that this focus on anti-obesity is turning so far the other way that weight is the foremost issue in people's minds. That's scary stuff. You think body image for young girls has been bad in the past? Wait for our kids to hit that age.

When I was about eight, I started worrying about my size. And I can tell you with absolute certainty that if anyone had spoken to me about diets or obesity or that fat equals bad, I would have plunged into some dark places. Of course, if there are health concerns they need to be addressed, for kids and adults alike, but let's focus on that keyword: HEALTH. Not how we look.

I recently had a chat to an eleven-year-old girl who told me she was on a diet. I gave her my usual anti-diet rant, and I told her she's perfect. (I also told her that if anyone ever tells her she's fat, to tell me and I'd beat them up. Before realising I'd just promoted violence. Ah well, you can't win them all.) I hope that she not only believes me, but hears it from so many people that she'll have no choice but to believe it.

That's what kids need to hear - from mums, dads, aunties, friends, everyone.

So the next child you see, please tell them how 'just right' they are. In a confusing world that's obsessed with so many things, they need some positivity.


7 comments:

  1. Absolutely! I think I'd do the same and skip that check if it was my child too. A 6 year old in my daughter's class told another classmate she should be on a diet!!! I couldn't believe it! Where does this stuff come from?! No wait, I know that answer!

    ReplyDelete
  2. There is one thing that has been picked up at this check by for a few friends' kids...eye sight. Even for those that seem perfectly fine. Heading to school the Principal also suggested all our Preps got an eye check too.

    Get her eyes checked somewhere, the rest you can miss, just fill it in yourself!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I like you when you have your ranty pants on...especially cos I agree with you! I stopped going to our maternal health nurse for those check up's & immunisations because I really dislike all the judgey mcjudgey from them. I take the boys to our GP who I love and trust and has got a better handle on the actual health of children wholistically. Those charts shit me no end! And we are taking S for his check soon too. I totally agree re body image issues too and I am certain boys will be just as impacted as girls henceforth too. So, so, so sad!

    ReplyDelete
  4. was told at Miss8's 4yo check up she was at risk of obesity … i DISSOLVED! and yelled. i don't know what else i did because i was so upset. suffice to say they rang me later and apologised, and admitted their bosses (ie, state government administrators) had told them they had to point it out to anyone above strict BMI guidelines.

    my daughter is not skinny (and i have heard parents proudly comparing how skinny their kids are) but she is active and eats a pretty good range of food … sure she has a sweet tooth (which i divert to fruit) and hates vegies (so does my hubby). but she has the rest of her life to understand good nutrition.

    to the world of BMI bullies, i say BOO! xt

    ReplyDelete
  5. What a moving post Megan. Body image shouldn't be projected onto children - they need to feel confident and worthy. So glad you're raising your little girl with such positive values about herself.

    ReplyDelete
  6. That is just plain weird. I bet your little girl is gorgeous and perfect. Those clinics are the cause of much anxiety for many parents. Stay away! x

    ReplyDelete
  7. My daughter at the age of 11 is very conscious of her body..she's a medium size.She ate balance food,which is i used to b'cos mu Mom trained us to eat veggie when i was a kid.So, i told her to not thinking of dieting. As long as she eat a balance food,she don't have to worry about her weight.

    ReplyDelete